The County Court cancelled a mental health crisis moratorium on the grounds of unfair prejudice and material irregularity, and granted an injunction preventing further applications for six months.
Summary
Regulation references in this summary are to the Debt Respite Scheme (Breathing Space Moratorium and Mental Health Crisis Moratorium) (England and Wales) Regulations 2020.
The County Court cancelled Mrs Smith’s sixth mental health crisis moratorium.
The moratorium unfairly prejudiced the Woodrows and there was a material irregularity because there was insufficient evidence that Mrs Smith met the eligibility requirements for a mental health crisis moratorium.
The court also granted a six-month injunction preventing the Smiths from applying for another mental health crisis moratorium without the court's permission. It allowed the creditors' bankruptcy proceedings to continue.
Background
The Smiths owed the Woodrows £128,741.79 plus interest following a dispute involving trespass relating to the placement of rubbish bins. The Smiths had not made any payment towards the debt.
The Woodrows served statutory demands on the Smiths in July 2023, followed by bankruptcy petitions in November 2023. The Smiths then entered a series of breathing space and mental health crisis moratoriums.
The first standard breathing space moratorium began in November 2023. Mrs Smith obtained six mental health crisis moratoriums shortly before scheduled bankruptcy hearings. Debt advice providers cancelled some of the earlier moratoriums because of issues including:
undisclosed assets
missing or inadequate documentation
a failure to confirm continuing mental health crisis treatment
The repeated moratoriums prevented the Woodrows from enforcing their judgment debt for more than a year.
The court considered the Woodrows’ applications to:
cancel the sixth mental health crisis moratorium
issue an injunction to prevent the Smiths from entering further mental health crisis moratoriums
award interest during the fourth, fifth and sixth mental health crisis moratoriums
proceed with bankruptcy proceedings against the Smiths
The court's decision
The court cancelled the sixth mental health crisis moratorium because it unfairly prejudiced the Woodrows and there had been a material irregularity. It also granted a six-month injunction preventing the Smiths from applying for another mental health crisis moratorium without the court's permission.
The court awarded interest for the sixth moratorium and allowed the Woodrows to proceed with bankruptcy proceedings against the Smiths.
Unfair prejudice
The court found that the moratorium unfairly prejudiced the Woodrows. The debt was substantial, had remained unpaid for a long period and was likely to continue growing. The Smiths had not engaged in finding a debt solution.
The timing and pattern of the moratorium applications were also significant. The court considered that they indicated an attempt to prevent enforcement rather than a genuine attempt to obtain debt advice.
Material irregularity
The court found material irregularity because there was insufficient evidence that Mrs Smith was receiving the treatment required for a mental health crisis moratorium under regulation 28.
Specifically, regulation 28(2)(e) requires the debtor to be receiving crisis, emergency or acute care or treatment from a specialist mental health service for a serious mental disorder.
Further moratorium applications
The court granted a six-month injunction preventing the Smiths from applying for another mental health crisis moratorium without the court's permission.
The court relied on its inherent jurisdiction and regulation 19(5), which allows the court to give supplemental directions as it considers appropriate.
Interest
The court awarded interest which had accrued during the sixth mental health crisis moratorium, but refused to award interest for the fourth and fifth moratoriums.
The court’s power to award interest applied only where it had cancelled a moratorium under regulation 19. The fourth and fifth moratoriums had been cancelled by the debt advice provider under regulation 34.
Bankruptcy proceedings
The court allowed the Woodrows to continue with bankruptcy proceedings against the Smiths, irrespective of the injunction on further applications for a mental health crisis moratorium.
The Smiths were using moratoriums to prevent enforcement rather than seek advice or enter a debt relief solution.
Comments
The decision shows that the court may restrict further mental health crisis moratorium applications where the evidence suggests repeated moratoriums are being used to delay enforcement. This follows a mixed approach in previous cases: in Kaye v Lees (2) the court granted a short injunction, while in Kaye v Lees (3) the High Court declined to extend it and said debt advice providers should usually decide whether a further moratorium is appropriate.
Repeated mental health crisis moratorium applications are not automatically abusive and must still be assessed against the statutory eligibility requirements and the facts of the case.
